Skip to main content

Argument and Counterargument

Argument and Counterargument:


The argument presented within my paper supports the idea that children with past lives are tangible and not only quantifiable in an area where a belief in reincarnation is present. Through this discovery, I used research questions discussing the possible patterns seen within a multitude of cases, discovering if children are just highly imaginative in their thinking that could cause this behavior, and recognizing cases not subjected in areas where reincarnation is of a firm belief. I believe these questions remove the assumption that a possible third variable that takes away the evidence within these cases is regarded as anything less than evidence pointing towards possible reincarnation. 

Within a source by Tucker, he presents an opposing idea (from another author) based on the socio-psychological hypothesis. It is a theory that can be loosely defined as the idea at which a child who has a family has a belief in reincarnation can then allow for the falsification of evidence (with the deceased's family) to something that points towards a case of reincarnation. In simpler terms, if I was someone who had a belief in reincarnation and my child was presenting minimal or minor signs of a child who was reincarnated, then I can then influence my child into believing (through falsification of facts with another family) that they were once reincarnated. This idea is proven by Tucker to be false through other reasoning based on tangible evidence. However, through my perspective, this idea fails to see that not all cases are ones where families are from areas where reincarnation is believed in. A statistic from Statista asked U.S teenagers about what theories or religious symbols they believed in. Here is where it was regarded that reincarnation was the least believed in and was the most “not believed” theory. This study is one that can be used to reflect the United States' beliefs. Within cases like Ryan Hammons, the parents had admitted to not believing in reincarnation when their son first presented signs of being reincarnated. With this idea, it makes it highly unlikely that people who at once refused to believe in reincarnation would go out of their way to make their son a center stage for researchers to regard him as one of the cases with the most highly verified case and one that is publicized for reincarnation. The sources that I used to build my argument come from Ryan’s mother herself, who, in both the book and Netflix production, admitted that she and her husband went through a time where they would not fully come to terms with reincarnation playing a part of their child’s reasoning for having these experiences. In addition to the statistics by Statista, and Tucker's article that first reports about this hypothesis (and also goes to disprove it with another variation of proof). 

Works Cited

Tucker, Jim B. “Children Who Claim to Remember Previous Lives: Past, Present, and Future Research.” Journal of Scientific Exploration, vol. 21, no. 3, 2007, pp. 543–52.

Harris Interactive. "U.S. Teenagers: Do You Believe in The following Theories and Religious Symbols?." Statista, Statista Inc., 22 Apr 2014, https://www-statista-com.proxy.libraries.rutgers.edu/statistics/297180/united-states-teenagers-religious-symbol-theories-belief/

Kean, Leslie. Surviving Death: a Journalist Investigates Evidence for an Afterlife. Three Rivers Press, an Imprint of the Crown Publishing Group, a Division of Penguin Random House LLC, 2018.




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Topics for Consideration

For this assignment, I had some difficulty deciding on the main topic that I would want to tackle. At first, I was considering looking into the Mandela Effect. I found this idea fascinating in terms of how a group of individuals can form a collective memory that somehow, in some cases, years later find out was misheard or misread. However, looking into the matter, I realized that some of the Mandela Effect’s examples were already things that I have always thought to be correct. In searching for another exciting topic, I came across the frequently asked question of what life is beyond death. As a child, like most other kids, there was this idea exposed to us of heaven and hell or this fantasy land that long-awaited us after death. However, having a Hindu upbringing, there is a major tenet towards reincarnation. For this project, I feel it would be interesting to explore the different ways that life after death is carried through different cultures, religions, and even how it is present...
1 comment
Read more

Scouting the Territory

My topic has not changed since the first blog post. I have not redefined it, but I know that I would like to also focus on the cases of children who remember their past lives. So while I explore the afterlife, I want to incorporate and add on the reincarnation aspect seen with these cases. Looking on Google, keywords like “afterlife,” “reincarnation,” and “children with past lives” opens up a realm of possibilities for exploring routes for the paper. The word “afterlife” showcased a variety of shows and documentaries from Time and Netflix. Using “reincarnation” brought me to links that we’re defining what the term meant, but interestingly, it also showed results of ways in which it’s real and the signs that prove it. On Wikipedia, most of the information was based on the different types of ways religions saw the afterlife and dove into the issue's psychological and philosophical sides. The arguments presented were just trying to find ways to prove what the afterlife is like and had...
1 comment
Read more

Research Questions and Scholarly Sources

Shifting away from the afterlife and into past lives, there needed to be a little bit of adjustment; however, I believe I included the research questions I’d like to explore. Many children are able to vividly remember and provide descriptions of what they preserve as their “past life.” How accurate are these cases, and do these cases pose any benefits for children? Are children just highly imaginative, and does a child’s highly developmental mind play a role in their experiences? Could there be any overlap between these children? Sources: Haraldsson, Erlendur. “Children Who Speak of Past-Life Experiences: Is There a Psychological Explanation?” Psychology & Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice, vol. 76, no. 1, Mar. 2003, p. 55. EBSCOhost, doi:10.1348/14760830260569256. Kean, Leslie. Surviving Death: a Journalist Investigates Evidence for an Afterlife. Three Rivers Press, an Imprint of the Crown Publishing Group, a Division of Penguin Random House LLC, 2018.  Pasricha,...
1 comment
Read more